Wagoner County, OK (March 27, 2025) – A devastating two-vehicle crash early Monday morning on the Muskogee Turnpike claimed the lives of two individuals and left another in critical condition. According to the Oklahoma Highway Patrol (OHP), the collision occurred around 4 a.m. at the 17-mile marker, approximately two miles west of Porter.
OHP confirmed that the crash involved two vehicles. The car, carrying three individuals, was severely impacted. Tragically, two passengers, identified as Baylor Butler and Stevie Carter, were pronounced dead at the scene by emergency responders. The driver of that vehicle sustained critical injuries and was rushed to a nearby hospital for treatment.
The driver of the second vehicle was reportedly unharmed and did not require medical transport.
Following the incident, the westbound lanes of the Muskogee Turnpike were closed for over four hours as investigators examined the scene and emergency crews worked to clear the wreckage. No further details have been released regarding how the crash occurred, and the official cause remains under active investigation by OHP.
Our hearts go out to the families of Baylor Butler and Stevie Carter, and we wish strength and healing to the injured driver during this difficult time.
Fatal Turnpike Collisions in Oklahoma
The tragic crash on the Muskogee Turnpike is a grim reminder of the risks that come with high-speed travel on Oklahoma’s turnpikes. Rural highways and toll roads—especially during early morning hours—can present significant hazards due to low visibility, fatigue, or unexpected traffic movement. With speeds often exceeding 70 mph, even a momentary misjudgment can result in catastrophic outcomes.
Two-vehicle crashes at highway speeds commonly lead to severe or fatal injuries, particularly when passengers bear the brunt of the impact. The fact that this crash claimed two lives and critically injured a third individual speaks to the violent nature of the collision. Investigators will likely examine factors such as speed, lane changes, driver attentiveness, and vehicle condition to determine how the crash occurred.
In cases like this, families are left not only grieving but also facing the emotional and logistical toll of a sudden tragedy. Immediate medical care, long-term rehabilitation, and funeral arrangements are just some of the urgent needs that arise in the aftermath of fatal crashes.
Support and clarity during these difficult times are essential. From understanding accident reports to navigating medical and legal next steps, having the right resources can ease the burden.
If you or someone you know has been affected by a serious or fatal crash in Oklahoma, Local Accident Reports is here to support your path forward. We connect families and survivors with trusted resources—from grief support to recovery guidance—so they don’t have to face these moments alone. Reach out to us today to get the help you need.
