Elkhart County, IN (February 25, 2026) – Officials have released new details following a deadly buggy crash that occurred on Friday, February 20, on State Road 4 south of Middlebury. On Tuesday, February 24, authorities identified the two children who lost their lives in the collision.
Police said 8-year-old Jenna Miller and 7-year-old Derek Bontrager died after a pickup truck struck the rear of a horse-drawn cart around 8 a.m. The impact happened along SR 4 in Elkhart County.
Two other children, ages 11 and 13, were also riding in the buggy at the time. Both were taken to a hospital with serious injuries. No updated information about their conditions has been released.
The crash remains under investigation. We extend our sincere condolences to the families of the children who lost their lives.
Why Are Horse-Drawn Buggy Crashes Often Severe?
Horse-drawn buggies travel at much lower speeds than motor vehicles. When a faster-moving vehicle approaches from behind, the difference in speed can increase the force of impact. This can lead to serious injuries, especially for young passengers.
Buggies offer limited protection compared to enclosed vehicles. They do not have seat belts, airbags, or reinforced frames. Rear-end crashes may throw occupants from the cart or cause major structural damage.
Rural highways such as State Road 4 are often shared by both motor vehicles and horse-drawn transportation. Drivers may encounter buggies during morning travel hours, making visibility and reaction time key factors in preventing collisions.
